Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access

Vortex Lift Contribution in Flapping Flight

Youngsun Hong

Abstract


Using steady state aerodynamic theories, it has been claimed that insects and birds cannot fly. To make matters worse, insects and birds fly at low Reynolds numbers. Therefore, a recurring theme in the literature is the
importance of understanding unsteady aerodynamic effect and how the vortices behave when they separate from the moving surface that created them. In flapping flight, birds and insects can modify wing beat amplitude, stroke angle, wing planform area, angle of attack, and to a lesser extent flapping frequency to optimize the generation of lift force. An important point to solving the mystery of insect flight is understanding vortex  shedding and how the vortices behave when they separate from the moving surface that created them. Insects depend on vortices to keep them aloft, especially when they are hovering. Vorticity is highly dependent on animal size, wing form, and flight speed and kinematics. To minimize energy expenditure during flight the birds should optimize the generation of the vortex wake. Some birds are thought to employ two different gaits(a
vortex-ring gait and a continuous-vortex gait) and unsteady aerodynamic effect(Clap and fling, Delayed stall, Wake capture and Rotational Circulation) in flapping flight. Leading edge vortices may produce an increase in lift. The trailing edge vortex could be an important component in gliding flight. Using a mechanical ornithopter with wings fabricated in-house, vortices were identified at several different locations along the span of the wing, and at numerous different points throughout the flapping cycle under a variety of operating conditions. The lift generated by these spanwise planar oriented vortices was quantified experimentally using Digital Particle Image Velocimetry. Thus, this study investigated how vortices generate lift in flapping motion.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Mueller Thomas J., “Aerodynamic Measurements At Low Reynolds Numbers For Fixed Wing Micro Air Vehicles”, University Of Notre Dame, 1999.

Prandtl, L., Tietjens, O. G., “Fundamentals Of Hydro and Aeromechanics”, Dover Publications, Inc., New York, pp.212-215,1957.

Khorrami, M.R, “Computational Simulations Of A Three Dimensional High Lift Wing”, AIAA-2002-2804, NASA Langley Research Center Hampton, VA.

Lian, Yongsheng And Shyy, Wei, “Numerical Simulations Of Membrane Wing Aerodynamics For Micro Air Vehicle Applications”, Journal Of Aircraft, Vol. 42, No. 4, July-August 2005.

Délery, J.M., Legendre,Robert And Werlé, Henri, “Toward The Elucidation Of Three-Dimensional Separation”, Annual Review Of Fluid Mechanics, Vol 33, pp.129 -154, 2001

Gursul, I., Lin, H. And Ho, C.-M., “Effects Of Time Scales On Lift Of Airfoils In An Unsteady Stream”, AIAA Journal, Vol 32, pp.797 -801, 1994.

Taylor, G.S., Schnorbus, T., And Gursul, I. “An Investigation Of Vortex Flows Over Low Sweep Delta Wings”, AIAA-2003-4021.

Huang. A, C, et al, “Application Of MEMS Devices To Delta Wing Aircraft: From Concept Development To Transonic Flight Test”, AIAA 2001-0124.

Gad-El-Hak, M. And Ho, C.-M., “The Pitching Delta Wing”, AIAA Journal, Vol 23, pp. 1660 -1665, 1985.

Mourtos, N. J. And Brooks, M. “Flow Past A Flat Plate With A Vortex/Sink Combination” Journal Of. Applied. Mechanics, Vol 63, pp. 543 -550, 1996.

Cox, J., “The Revolutionary Kasper Wing”, Soaring, Vol 37, pp.20-23, Dec. 1973.

Rossow, V.J., “Lift Enhancement By An Externally Trapped Vortex. AIAA Paper 77-672, 1977.

Riddle, T.W, et al, “Experimental Analysis Of Vortex Trapping Techniques”, Journal Of Fluid Engineering Vol 121. pp.555-559, 1991.

Huang M.K, Chow C.Y, “Trapping Of A Free Vortex By Joukowski Airfoil”, AIAA 82-4059, 1982.

Weis-Fogh, T. “Quick Estimates Of Flight Fitness In Hovering Animals, Including Novel Mechanisms For Lift Production”, Journal Of Experimental Biology, Vol.59. pp.169-230, 1973.

Dickinson, M. H. And Götz, K. G. “Unsteady Aerodynamic Performance Of Model Wings At Low Reynolds Numbers”, Journal Of Experimental Biology, Vol.174. pp.45-64, 1993.

Dickinson M.H, Lehmann F.O, Sane S.P, “Wing Rotation And The Aerodynamic Basis Of Insect Flight”, Science, Vol. 284. pp.1954-1960, 1999.

Anders John B., “Biomimetic Flow Control,” AIAA-2000-2543.

Tyson L. Hedrick And Bret W. Tobalske, “Estimates Of Circulation And Gait Change On A Three-Dimensional Kinematic Analysis Of Flight In Cockatiels (Nymphicus Hollandicus) And Ringed Turtle-Doves (Streptopelia

Risoria)”, The Journal Of Experimental Biology, Vol.205, pp.1389–1409, 2002.

Powell K.L., Parker K. And Soria J., “Flow Visualization Of Forced Flow Control Over Inclined Aerofoils”, 15th Australasian Fluid Mechanics Conference, Sydney, Australia, December 2004.

Cheng, M., Moretti, P. M., “Lock-In Phenomena On A Single Cylinder With Forced Transverse Vibration”, See Au-Yang & Hara, pp 129-133, 1991.

Moretti P. M., “Flow-Induced Vibrations in Arrays of Cylinders”, Annual Review Of Fluid Mechanics, Vol. 25, pp.99-114, 1993.

Lattimer, J. M. and Prakash M., “The physics of Neutron Star”, Science, Vol. 304 (5670), pp.536-541, 2004 (Http://scienceweek.com/2004/Sc040730-4.html).

Ho S., et al. “Unsteady Aerodynamics And Flow Control For Flapping Wing Flyers”, Progress In Aerospace Sciences Vol. 39, pp.635–681, 2003.

Taylor, G And et al, “Flying And Swimming Animals Cruise At A Strouhal Number Tuned For High Power Efficiency” Nature, Vol 425, pp. 707-711, 2003.

Triantafyllou, M. S., Triantafyllou, G. S. & Gopalkrishnan, R. “Wake Mechanics For Thrust Generation In Oscillating Foils”, Physics Of Fluids A. Vol.3, pp.2835- 2837, 1991.

Wang Z Jane, “Vortex Shedding And Frequency Selection In Flapping Flight”, Journal Of Fluid Mechanics, Vol 410, pp. 323-341, 2000.

Jones, K. D. And Platzer, M. E., “Time-Domain Analysis Of Low-Speed Airfoil Flutter”, AIAA Journal, Vol.34 No.5, pp.1027-1033, 1996.

Willmott, A. P., Ellington, C. P. And Thomas, A. L. R., “Flow Visualization And Unsteady Aerodynamics In The Flight Of The Hawkmoth, Manduca Sexta”,Phiosophical Transaction Of Royal Society Of London. B, Vol.352, pp.303 -316, 1997.

Ellington, C. P., Van Den Berg, C. And Willmott, A. P., “Leading Edge Vortices In Insect Flight”, Nature, Vol. 384, pp. 626 - 630, 1996.

Pornsin-Sisirak T., Tai Y.C., et al, “Microbat- A Palm-Sized Electrically Powered Ornithopter”, 2001 NASA/JPL Workshop On Biomorphic Robotics, Pasadena, CA, Aug 2000.

Jones, K. D. And Platzer, M. E., “Time-Domain Analysis Of Low-Speed Airfoil Flutter”, AIAA Journal, Vol.34 No.5, pp.1027-1033, 1996.

Lewin, G. C. And Haj-Hariri, H. “Modelling Thrust Generation Of A Two-Dimensional Heaving Airfoil In A Viscous Flow”, Journal Of Fluid Mechanics,Vol. 492, pp.339 -362, 2003.

Maxworthy T., “Experiments On The Weis Fogh Mechanism Of Lift Generation By Insects In Hovering Flight. Part 1. Dynamics Of The ‘Fling’”, Journal Of Fluid Mechanics, Vol 93, Part 1. pp. 47-63, 1979.

Birch J.M, Dickinson M.H, “Spanwise Flow And The Attachment Of The Leading-Edge Vortex On Insect Wings”, Nature, Vol 412,pp 688-689, 2001.

Bomphrey, R.J., et al, “The Aerodynamics Of Manduca Sexta: Digital Particle Image Velocimetry Analysis Of The Leading-Edge Vortex”, The Journal Of Experiemntal Biology, Vol 208, pp. 1079-1094, 2005.

Ellington, C. P., Van Den Berg, C. And Willmott, A. P., “Leading Edge Vortices In Insect Flight”, Nature, Vol. 384, pp. 626 - 630, 1996.

Luttges, M., “Accomplished Insect Fliers in Frontiers In Experimental Fluid Mechanics (Ed. M. Gad-El-Hak),” pp. 429-456. Berlin: Springer, 1989.

Van Den Berg, C., and Ellington, C. P., “The Three-Dimensional Leading-Edge Vortex of a `Hovering' Model Hawkmoth,” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B, Vol.352, pp.329 -340, 1997.

Birch, J. M., Dickson W. B. and Dickinson, M H., “Force Production and Flow Structure of the Leading Edge Vortex on Flapping Wings at High and Low Reynolds Numbers,” Journal of Experimental Biology, Vol. 207, pp.1063-1072, 2003.

Maxworthy, T., “The Dynamics of Insect Flight,” Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, Vol.13, 1981.

Warrick, D.R., Tobalske, B.W., and Powers, D.R., “Aerodynamics of the Hovering Hummingbird,” Nature, Vol. 435, pp. 1094-1097, 2005.

Srygley R.B., Thomas A.L.R. “Unconventional Lift-Generating Mechanisms In Free-Flying Butterflies”, Nature, Vol 420. pp.660-664, 2002.

Ellington, C. P., “Unsteady Aerodynamics Of Insect Flight”, Symposia Of The Society For Experimental Biology, Vol. 49, pp. 109–129, Cambridge: The Company Of Biologists Ltd., 1995.

Brodsky, A. K. “The Evolution Of Insect Flight”, New York: Oxford University Press, 1994.

Grodnitsky, D. L., Morozov, P. P. “Flow Visualization Experiments On Terthered Flying Green Lacewings Chrysopa Dasyptera”, Journal Of Experimental Biology, Vol, 169, pp. 143–163, 1992.

Grodnitsky, D. L., Morozov, P. P., “Vortex Formation During Tethered Flight Of Functionally And Morphologically Two winged Insects, Including Evolutionary Considerations On Insect Flight”, Journal Of Experimental Biology, Vol 182, pp. 11–40, 1993.

Spedding, G. R. And Maxworthy, T., “The Generation Of Circulation And Lift In A A Rigid Two-Dimensional Fling”, Journal Of Fluid Mechanics, Vol 165, pp. 247–272, 1986.

Spedding, G. R., Rayner, J. M. V. And Pennycuick, C. J., “Momentum And Energy In The Wake Of A Pigeon (Columba Livia) In Slow Flight”, Journal Of Experimental Biology, Vol 111, pp. 81–102, 1984.

Rayner, J. M. V., Jones, G. And Thomas, A., “Vortex Flow Visualizations Reveal Change In Upstroke Function With Flight Speed In Bats”, Nature 321, pp.162–164, 1986.

Dickinson, M. H. And Gotz K.G., “The Wake Dynamics And Flight Forces Of The Fruit Fly Drosophila Melanogaster”, The Journal Of Experimental Biology, Vol 199, pp. 2085–2104, 1996.

Pennycuick, C. J., “Mechanics Of Flight. In Avian Biology”, Vol. 5, pp. 1-75. London: Academic Press, 1975.

Miller, L A. And Peskin, C. S., “When Vortices Stick: An Aerodynamic Transition In Tiny Insect Flight”, Journal Of Experimental Biology, Vol 207, pp.3073-3088, 2004.

Birch, J. M. And Dickinson, M. H. “The Influence Of Wing-Wake Interactions On The Production Of Aerodynamic Forces In Flapping Flight” Journal Of Experimental Biology, Vol 206, pp. 2257 -2272, 2003.

Liu H., Ellington, C.P. et al,, “A Computational Fluid Dynamic Study of Hawkmoth Hovering”, The Journal Of Experimental Biology, Vol.201, pp.461–477, 1998.

Kokshaysky. N.V, “Tracing The Wake Of A Flying Bird”, Nature, Vol. 279. pp.146-148, 1979.

Lighthill, M. J. “On The Weis-Fogh Mechanism Of Lift–Generation”, Journal Of Fluid Mechanics, Vol.60. pp.1-17, 1973.

Rayner, J. M, “Estimating Power Curves Of Flying Vertebrates”, Journal Of Experimental Biology, Vol. 202, 1999.

Park CD, Matuda K, Tokai T, “Flow Visualization Around Cambered Plates Using Hydrogen Bubbles”, Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, Vol.60, pp.485-491, 1994.

Westerweel Jerry, “Digital Particle Image Velocimetry- Theory & Application,” Delft University Press, 1993.

Alford, L. and Altman, A., “Foundation Of A New Investigation Of Natural Flight Characteristics And Theory,” AIAA-2005-1357, 43rd AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit, Reno, Nevada.

Ellington. C.P., “The Novel Aerodynamics of Insect Flight: Applications to Micro-Air Vehicles,” Journal of Experimental Biology, Vol. 202, pp. 3439-3448, 1999.

Lin, J.-C., Rockwell, D., “Force Identification by Vorticity Fields: Techniques Based on Flow Imaging,” Journal of Fluids and Structures, Vol. 10, pp. 663 – 668, 1996.

Lighthill, James, “Fundamentals Concerning Wave Loading On Offshore Structures”, Journal of Fluid Mechanics, Vol 173, 1986.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.21535%2FProICIUS.2007.v3.624

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.